Dare I even go here?
I just heard something on Good Morning America that has me fired up. A mom in California posted a blog entry attacking Elizabeth Edwards for her choice to take her children on the road during her husband John Edwards' political campaign for president. She called her a "terrible mother," and told her, "Elizabeth, I DON'T LIKE the choices you have made! TAKE YOUR KIDS HOME!"
I love that Elizabeth Edwards spoke her mind and responded. She wasn't polished and reserved, like many politicians and their wives. She stood up for herself with a ferocious determination I truly respect. She said, "….you have no idea what the quality or amount of the time I spend with my children is….You don't get to say I am a terrible mother because you think you wouldn't make my choices in my situation…You don't get to judge me because you think you know exactly what you would do if you had my disease. I want to be really clear: you don't know. And if the sun always shines on you -- and I pray it does -- you will never know."
Why do some moms feel they have to attack other moms, passing off their own personal choices and opinions on what they believe to be the best (or only) way to mother as some written doctrine? And if one chooses a different path, she risks being shunned or disgraced in some small world of other mothers with similar opinions.
I have been a mother for more than five years now, and I can't tell you how many times this debate has reared its head in my own life. I have definitely felt criticism -- from my own friends, sometimes -- who have strong opinions about staying home with their kids vs. working "outside of the home."
I understand the passion behind motherhood, and I understand that many women feel that there is no other duty in this life that's more important than being a mother. And I agree, in some regard. But why do some moms feel they need to attack other moms and pass judgment upon them when they choose to work?
Mothers who are passionate about loving their children, one would think, would be loving, caring and understanding individuals. But for some reason, when it comes to other mothers and the choices they make, the gloves come off, and it's all-out war.
I choose to work because I love what I do. It's not my nature to stay at home. Frankly, I'd be terrible at it. I think stay-at-home moms have the absolute hardest job on the planet. I believe that 100%. I have a very high respect for stay-at-home moms. Very high. They're more patient with and understanding of kids than I probably am. I know that SAHMs are not sitting around baking cookies, coloring with their kids all day, taking naps and watching soap operas. I know that's not how it is, because I have two kids of my own, with whom I stay home two days out of the workweek. We're lucky to do one fun thing the entire week. I spend more time playing referee, trying to keep them from killing each other, changing diapers, picking up toys and 100 other things that wouldn't have been on the list of things I thought I'd do with my kids if I had the chance to be home all day. I also see several of my friends who are lucky enough to be able to stay at home with their kids, and I know it's stressful. It's work. Even though they absolutely love their kids and have the biggest hearts in the world, it's work to stay at home.
Dr. Phil, Oprah, Good Morning America, the Today Show and countless other television programs, magazines, books, newspapers and more have covered this topic. There are Web sites and blogs devoted to it. I remember an episode of Dr. Phil a couple of years ago (and no, I don't sit home watching Dr. Phil all day, either) when they had the audience split down the middle -- working moms on one side, and stay-at-home moms on the other. You would have thought it was two feuding countries in the same room. These women were vicious to each other.
Why does it matter? Why does it matter to anyone else if I choose to work? It's making me happy, and if I'm happy, I'm much more likely to be a good mom. Staying home with my kids, personally, would make me miserable. Not because I don't enjoy spending time with them -- I do. I love them with all of my heart, and there are no two people on this planet who make me happier. And I am constantly trying to figure out how to achieve the best balance between work life and family life. But I wouldn't be happy as a full-time mom. I know that, and I'm honest with myself about it. I'd be terribly grumpy, impatient and not too fun to be around if I didn't have a chance to be creative in my work, earn a living at it, and have a chance to interact with people (adults) with a similar nature as mine. Why do some other moms feel they have to judge me for that?
I say, whatever works best for every individual mom is the right choice. My situation might not be right for other moms, and so I would never try to convince them that it was the only way to do it. Similarly, the stay-at-home situation isn't right for me, and I don't want other moms making me feel as though I'm putting my own needs in front of my children's. Why can't we all just agree that we're all different people, and we all live different lives, and we all have a right to do whatever is best for us?
I'm tired of the Mommy Wars.